Ernest Hemingway For Whom the Bell Tolls - 

Unsere Webseite nutzt Cookies. Wenn Sie auf dieser Webseite bleiben, nehmen wir an, dass Sie damit einverstanden sind. Sie können unsere Cookies löschen. Wie das geht, erfahren Sie in unserer Datenschutzerklärung. Mehr erfahren

Impressum | Datenschutzerklärung Startseite


Ernest Hemingway For Whom the Bell Tolls

  Note: 2   Klasse: 11

Arbeit: In June 1937, Ernest Hemingway addressed the Second Congress of

American Writers at Carnegie Hall in New York City. His subject was

the Spanish Civil War, which had started in 1936 and which he had

observed first-hand for some months as a correspondent of the North

American Newspaper Alliance. In his speech, which was warmly

received by the audience, Hemingway spoke of his deep hatred for the

fascist forces trying to overthrow the Republican government in Spain,

particularly for the way they suppressed artists, notably writers.

"Really good writers are always rewarded under almost any existing

system of government that they can tolerate," Hemingway said in his

speech. "There is only one form of government that cannot produce good

writers, and that system is fascism. For fascism is a lie told by

bullies. A writer who will not lie cannot live and work under


Hemingway's apparent devotion to the Republican cause in this war

was greeted with cheers by liberals in the United States. Here was

Ernest Hemingway, a famous novelist, declaring his allegiance to their

cause! His pledge of support seemed particularly welcome, since he had

long resisted public political commitment of any kind and had been

criticized for his reluctance to become involved in the important

issues of the day. Now he had thrown himself into the midst of the


Hemingway returned to Spain to watch the battle rage, and he

became increasingly frustrated by the failure of the Republicans to

hold their own against the fascist rebels. He was also sickened by the

corruption and ineptness of Republicans and Nationalists alike. He

called this situation "the carnival of treachery and rottenness on

both sides," and was especially critical of the military leaders.

Hemingway decided that he could best serve the Republican cause by

writing about the war as honestly as possible. "The hell with war

for awhile," he said, "I want to write." The result of his creative

urge was the novel For Whom the Bell Tolls, which was published in

1940, the year after the Republicans had lost the war.


* * *


For someone who lived his adult years with bold, muscular strokes in

public view across three continents, Hemingway's early life was

relatively uneventful. He was born in Oak Park, Illinois, a suburb

of Chicago, on July 21, 1899. His mother was artistic and cultured,

and might have followed a career as an opera singer. She tried to urge

Ernest to develop musical inclinations, but with no results. His great

love was the outdoors, the appreciation of which he learned from his

father, a physician, who relished fishing, hunting, and the lore of

the woods. Ernest acquired ideals of endurance, physical prowess,

and courage that later show up in his writing and his life.

When he was graduated from high school in 1917, Hemingway had no

desire to go to college. His interest was World War I, which had

been raging for three years. He wanted to participate before the

fighting ended, but he was met by disappointment. At first Hemingway's

father refused to let him enlist, and when his father finally

relented, the American armed forces rejected Hemingway for poor vision

in one eye.

Hemingway then worked as a reporter for the Kansas City Star for six

months until he found a way to participate in the war- as an ambulance

driver with the American Red Cross. By June 1918 he was at the front

lines in Italy. During a furious Austrian shelling of Italian

troops, he carried a wounded soldier to safety, but was struck along

the way by pieces of mortar shrapnel.

The Italian government decorated Hemingway for his heroism,

newspapers printed glowing stories, and a hero's welcome awaited him

in Oak Park. But Hemingway was nonetheless plagued by rejection in

other areas: He had fallen in love with Agnes von Kurowsky, a nurse

who had cared for him in an Italian hospital, but in 1919 she broke

off their relationship. And his determination to be a writer was

dampened by rejection slips from one magazine after another.

Coloring almost everything was his disillusionment with the values

he had learned while growing up. His experience in the war overseas

had changed his outlook, and he became more and more estranged from

his parents. In Europe he encountered cynicism about the war, not

patriotism, and there was an overwhelming loss of hope and belief in

traditional values.

In September 1921, Hemingway married Hadley Richardson. The couple

moved to Paris, where Hemingway served as a correspondent for The

Toronto Star. Paris was a gathering place for American expatriates-

people who chose to live away from their homeland, mostly because they

were disillusioned or confused about their lives and their country.

One writer dubbed these rootless people "the lost generation."

Hemingway's desire to be a full-time writer of fiction was still

unfulfilled. Manuscript after manuscript was turned down by

publishers. Another devastating blow came in December 1923 when a

suitcase containing almost everything he had written was stolen and

never recovered.

But in 1924 a small collection of his short stories, in our time,

was published in Paris. In 1925, retitled with capitals, In Our Time

was published in the United States and ultimately received high

critical praise. His terse, direct style (developed in part by his

need to use as few words as possible as a foreign correspondent) and

his ability to articulate intense, complex emotions without flowery

excess, was greeted with warm welcome by many critics, who saw him

as helping initiate a departure from the verbal indulgences of many

writers of the 19th century. Hemingway further polished his style in

his first novel, The Sun Also Rises (1926). The book, a telling

depiction of life among American expatriates in Europe, was warmly

received by both critics and the reading public.

In 1927, Hemingway divorced Hadley and married Pauline Pfeiffer, a

writer for Vogue magazine. They moved to Key West, Florida, where he

worked on A Farewell to Arms (1929) and Pauline gave birth to the

first of their two sons. Just as he was completing the final draft

of A Farewell to Arms, which would bring him even more critical and

financial success, he learned that his father- despondent and ill with

diabetes- had shot himself to death. Hemingway considered suicide a

cowardly act, and never forgave his father for it. Yet the suicide

would ultimately have a grim echo in Hemingway's own life.

The 1930s brought Hemingway adventure and broad, bold experiences.

He indulged his love for deep-sea fishing off the coast of Florida and

hunting in the American West and Africa. Always seeking intense

physical experience, Hemingway spoke with awe about the thrill of

the "clean kill." He wrote many magazine articles that glorified these

brawny adventures, until the public generally identified him with

the image of the hearty and rugged outdoorsman. Hemingway wrote two

nonfiction books during this period, Death in the Afternoon (1932),

which honored the ritual of the bullfight, and Green Hills of Africa

(1935), detailing the glory of an African safari.

The Great Depression and other world problems helped develop a new

side of Hemingway. Because the heroes in Hemingway's novels had been

loners, independent and aloof from the problems of the masses, the

generally left-leaning writers of the time disdained him and his

outlook. That's one major reason why Hemingway was cheered so heartily

in his address in 1937 to the Congress of American Writers: this was a

new, politically committed Ernest Hemingway!

Hemingway's zeal for the Republican, or Loyalist, cause was revealed

in actions as well as words. He accompanied both regular Republican

army groups and guerrilla bands as a correspondent. He spent time in

the Spanish cities, in the countryside, in the mountains. He also

bought ambulances for the Loyalists, and helped prepare a pro-Loyalist

documentary film, The Spanish Earth.

There was another aspect of Hemingway that lured him to the scene of

battle- his love of conflict itself. It would be simplistic to say

that Hemingway glorified war, as some have charged. He was as sickened

by its cruelty and waste as anyone could be. Yet he was also excited

by what he saw as the more positive aspects of battle- courage,

camaraderie, loyalty, dedication to a cause. According to one

observer, Hemingway was "attracted by danger, death, great deeds";

another said he was "revived and rejuvenated" by seeing those who

refused to surrender, no matter what the odds. Hemingway was also

buoyed by what he called "the pleasant, comforting stench of comrades"

fighting together for a common goal. Instincts similar to those that

drew him to a bullfight or to the stalking of wild game sharpened

his senses during the Spanish Civil War.

It is the conflicting impulses of attraction and repulsion that

create much of the tension in For Whom the Bell Tolls. The publication

of the novel was greeted with acclaim by some, but with disdain by

others. Some liberals and some conservatives were angered because they

felt Hemingway had betrayed them by not writing a novel that favored

their respective political outlook. But Hemingway responded, "In

stories about the war I try to show all the different sides of it,

taking it slowly and honestly and examining it in many ways. So

never think one story represents my viewpoint because it is much too

complicated for that."

For Whom the Bell Tolls was a great commercial success. Paramount

Pictures acquired the film rights for $150,000, an astronomical sum at

the time. Hemingway stipulated who the principal actors should be- the

very popular Gary Cooper would be Robert Jordan, the main figure in

the novel, and the rising star Ingrid Bergman would be Maria, the

guerrilla with whom Jordan falls in love.

In the later 1940s and 50s, the novel's critical standing declined

compared with some of Hemingway's other works. Readers noted

inaccuracies in the use of Spanish in For Whom the Bell Tolls. They

criticized details of the presentation of Spanish culture, such as the

scene where Agustin, a Spanish guerrilla, asks Jordan about Maria's

sexual performance. Such curiosity would violate a strict Spanish code

of decorum. Other readers said the relationship between Jordan and

Maria lacked credibility.

In more recent times the novel has regained critical stature. Some

regard it as Hemingway's finest achievement. And few doubt the

personal passion and experience he brought to its writing.

How objective a reporter was Hemingway? Can you read For Whom the

Bell Tolls as an accurate picture of Spain during the civil war?

Opinions vary. His war correspondence itself has received labels

that range from "stirring accounts" to "a kind of sub-fiction in which

he was the central character."

In For Whom the Bell Tolls he was objective enough to point out

deficiencies of the Republican side and to write vividly of the

atrocities they committed. He could also show the enemy in a favorable

light. For instance, in the novel's final scene, the representative of

the Nationalists, Lieutenant Berrendo, is not an odious barbarian

but a richly human character for whom you may feel considerable


The famous British writer George Orwell, whose books include 1984

and Animal Farm, was another of the many leading writers who became

actively involved in the Spanish Civil War. He wrote Homage to

Catalonia (1938), a detailed recollection of experiences with one of

the Loyalist organizations. You might want to compare the fictional

details of For Whom the Bell Tolls with Orwell's account of the way he

saw the war. You will also learn about the war by reading Arthur

Koestler's Spanish Testament (1937), a vivid account of the writer's

imprisonment by Nationalist forces. Man's Hope (1938), by the noted

French intellectual Andre Malraux, is considered a masterly

depiction of early stages of the war. In addition, several

historical works on the Spanish Civil War contain a wealth of

material. Such studies include books by Gabriel Jackson (1965), Hugh

Thomas (1977), and Peter Wyden (1983).

Hemingway's second marriage ended in divorce in 1940, and he married

Martha Gellhorn, a writer and foreign correspondent during the Spanish

Civil War. For Whom the Bell Tolls is dedicated to her.

World War II (1939-45) captivated Hemingway. Both his finances and

his reputation were solid, and he needed neither the notoriety nor the

money from being a war correspondent. Nevertheless, he took a job as

chief of the European bureau of Collier's magazine. He accompanied the

British Royal Air Force on several bombing raids over occupied

France and crossed the English Channel with American troops on

D-Day, June 6, 1944. He was in the thick of fighting during the

liberation of Paris and the Battle of the Bulge, often seeming as much

a soldier as a correspondent, according to one source.

In 1945, at the age of 46, Hemingway divorced Martha Gellhorn and

married his last wife, Mary Welsh. The couple lived on a luxurious

estate outside Havana, Cuba, until the revolution begun in 1959 by

Fidel Castro forced them to leave.

Hemingway's novel Across the River and Into the Trees (1950) was

eagerly awaited. But when published it was scorned, receiving

biting, almost vicious, reviews. Critics accused Hemingway of

writing self-parody; another claimed to feel "pity, embarrassment,

that so fine and honest a writer can make such a travesty of himself."

It became fashionable to consider Hemingway washed up as a writer.

Returning to Africa to re-create some of the adventures of the

1930s, Hemingway was nearly killed in an airplane crash. But he

survived, and went on to write The Old Man and the Sea in 1952, the

last major work published while he was alive. (A Moveable Feast,

Islands in the Stream, By-line: Ernest Hemingway, and The Dangerous

Summer were published after his death.) The Old Man and the Sea

revived Hemingway's flagging career. He received a Pulitzer Prize

for the book, and it helped him win the prestigious Nobel Prize for

literature in 1954.

In subsequent years the hearty and death-defying Hemingway began

to lose his health. Nothing, including visits to the Mayo Clinic in

Minnesota, was able to restore him to his previous vigor. His

illnesses (including a rare disease that affects the vital organs)

were compounded by severe states of depression.

Did he decide that, if he could not live as aggressively and

boldly as he once had, he would prefer not to live at all? Whatever

the reason, he took his own life at his home in Ketchum, Idaho, on

July 2, 1961. He shot himself with a silver-inlaid shotgun, choosing a

method used by his father years earlier. He thus duplicated an act

that he had denounced as cowardly.

Hemingway the artist left a rich legacy of work that has found a

permanent place in American literature. That he is likely to endure

can be attributed to many factors, but is perhaps best summed up in

his own words, spoken to the Writer's Congress in 1937: "A writer's

problem... is always how to write truly and having found out what is

true to project it in such a way that it becomes part of the

experience of the person who reads it." Hemingway wrote truly, and

he becomes part of everyone who reads him.






For Whom the Bell Tolls tells the engrossing tale of Robert

Jordan, an American supporter of the Republican cause in the Spanish

Civil War (1936-39). Within a short span of some 68 hours, Jordan's

involvement with a band of guerrillas- notably a young woman named

Maria, with whom he falls in love- forces him to question his own

participation in a war that seems unwinnable and to realize that the

sacrifice of life for the sake of a political cause may be too high

a price to pay.

Jordan is a college teacher on a leave of absence in Spain, and as

For Whom the Bell Tolls opens, he's discussing the location of a

bridge with a local guide named Anselmo. But there's much more to

the situation than that. The Spain that Jordan loves is involved in

a civil war, and he has really come to help wage that war on behalf of

the side he believes in. At the moment his job is to blow up a

bridge behind enemy lines.

The assignment came to Jordan through General Golz, a Soviet officer

also in Spain to help fight the war. According to Golz, the demolition

of the bridge at precisely the right moment is a key part of a

large-scale offensive by the Republican forces.

Jordan needs help to do the job, so the peasant Anselmo has

brought him to a guerrilla band hiding in the mountains. From the

moment Jordan meets Pablo, their leader, Jordan suspects that the

guerrilla chief, who should be his chief ally in the operation, will

spell trouble.

Pablo has "gone bad." He's lost his drive, his purpose as a

guerrilla leader. He's content simply to stay hidden and survive,

rather than actively harass the enemy.

With the arrival of Jordan, the band of seven men and two women

are given a renewed sense of purpose. This prompts a showdown for

leadership of the band. Pilar, Pablo's mistress, publicly assumes

charge. Pablo's status is uncertain at this moment, and several of the

band would now be grateful if Jordan killed Pablo. But he doesn't.

Plans are made to enlist the help of a neighboring guerrilla band, led

by El Sordo, in the demolition of the bridge.

Robert Jordan finds more than the bridge to occupy his attention.

Among the guerrilla group is Maria, a young woman who was rescued by

the band during their last significant operation. They are almost

instantly attracted to each other and spend this first night making

love. It's not the first sexual experience for either of them.

Jordan has been with other women; Maria was once raped by a group of

enemy soldiers. But for each, it's the first experience that

combines sex with love.

On the second day, Jordan, Pilar, and Maria make their way to the

hideout of El Sordo to enlist his help in demolishing the bridge. El

Sordo promises support. On the return trip, Pilar deliberately

leaves Jordan and Maria by themselves for a while. Again they make

love, and Jordan begins to entertain serious doubts about whether this

war is the most important thing in his life after all.

The band now observes a heavy concentration of enemy soldiers riding

through the area but manages to avoid detection. El Sordo and his

men are not so fortunate. Nationalist soldiers- the enemy- trap them

on a hill and they are slaughtered. Jordan and the others hear the

sounds of the fighting but are helpless to come to El Sordo's aid.

It's an agonizing feeling.

Personal experiences have brought Jordan to doubt the value of

this war in general. Now the concentration of enemy soldiers and

planes in the area makes him doubt the practicality of blowing up

the bridge. Perhaps if Golz were aware of the enemy's numbers in the

immediate area, he would want the operation canceled.

He writes a dispatch to Golz. But the messenger is delayed time

and again- not by the presence of the enemy in the area, but by the

frustrating bumbling and petty bureaucracy of his own Republican

forces. Ultimately, he is arrested and the dispatch is confiscated,

again by his own people.

At the camp, Maria and Jordan dream about their future together, but

Jordan knows they are fooling themselves. Finally, Pilar brings Jordan

the news that Pablo has deserted and has taken the detonation devices.

The bridge operation wasn't easy to begin with; now Jordan will have

to improvise a makeshift exploder and detonators just to have a chance

at succeeding.

He spends the middle of the night devising a way- and holding Maria.

"We'll be killed but we'll blow the bridge," he whispers to her as she

sleeps in his arms.

Early on the morning of this fourth day, as the band eat what

could be their last breakfast, Pablo returns. He apologizes for his

moment of weakness. To make up for it, he has brought several more men

from the area to join them. But the exploder and detonators are

gone; he has tossed them in the river.

Meanwhile, a Soviet journalist secures the release of the messenger,

and Jordan's dispatch finally reaches Golz, but it's too late. The

doomed attack has already been mounted and can't be stopped.

Without counterorders from Golz, Jordan's mission to blow up the

bridge proceeds. He feverishly rigs the improvised detonation

devices just in time. At the sound of the Loyalist attack (his cue),

the bridge is blown up. Jordan has accomplished what he came to do.

But he is a different man from what he was a short while ago; the

success gives him little satisfaction.

The band must now attempt a retreat. Pablo, the most familiar with

the area, has devised a workable plan. The group draws enemy fire

but no one is hit. They all have a chance to escape to a safe area-

except Robert Jordan.

His horse is hit and falls on him, breaking his thigh. For the

good of all, he is left behind. Everyone but Maria can see that

there is no other way. There is a painful good-bye. Maria protests

to the end and won't leave until she is forced to by Pilar and Pablo.

Robert Jordan struggles to remain conscious just long enough to kill

at least some of the enemy. He lies on the ground, awaiting the enemy.







Robert Jordan is a man of action. In For Whom the Bell Tolls, he

undertakes a dangerous mission, even welcomes it. Like other Hemingway

heroes, he seems to understand that dying well can be even more

important than living well.

But unlike other Hemingway heroes, Jordan believes in an abstract

ideal, an ideology, a cause. This cause is "government by the

people" in the Spain that he loves. Jordan's liberal political views

have motivated him to leave the University of Montana where he teaches

Spanish, in order to fight with the Spanish Republicans, or Loyalists.

Whereas most liberal intellectuals were willing only to denounce in

words the rise of fascism in Spain, Jordan takes action in support

of his political beliefs.

Beyond that, Jordan is intelligent, clever, inventive, and decisive.

He can keep his composure in sticky situations. These qualities are

necessary for survival in his role in Spain of a demolition expert

behind enemy lines.

Jordan is unquestionably in charge, except in the arena of his own

mind. Here, he begins to question and reevaluate the very ideals

that brought him to Spain. This tormented individualist sways and

wavers, experiencing moments of painful honesty and moments of

self-deception. He sometimes feels caught between new values

emerging in his life and a duty he has committed himself to.

At the conclusion of Hemingway's story, dedication to an ideology is

not as important to Jordan as it was at the beginning. He begins to

see that his cause is tarnished, that perhaps every cause is

tarnished. He has changed from a believer in abstract ideas to a

believer in the importance of the individual person.

You might accept this change as both credible and authentic, or

you might question it on the grounds that it's motivated principally

by his rather swift and passionate love affair with Maria. You'll have

to decide whether Jordan is more genuine or less genuine at the

conclusion of the novel- or equally so, even though his principal

allegiance has changed.



Pablo, the leader of the guerrilla band, is one of Hemingway's

richest characters. In one sense he is quite entertaining, not only

because he is frequently comically drunk but also because his behavior

is full of surprises.

At one time, there had been an entirely different Pablo, who, like

Jordan, believed strongly in the Loyalist cause. But unlike Jordan,

that Pablo was capable of immense cruelty.

Now the guerrilla leader is disillusioned. The cause means little to

him. He's content simply to survive, hidden in the mountains, doing

almost nothing to aid the Loyalist forces. Given his horses and his

wine, he appears happy.

On the surface, he seems to have degenerated into an ineffective

force. But he cannot be discounted. In fact, his bitter

disillusionment makes him dangerous. He's capable now of

deliberately sabotaging the very operations he formerly supported

and led.

Yet something of the old Pablo remains. He may have lost his

motivation and the firmness of his allegiance, but he hasn't lost

his cleverness and expertise as a guerrilla soldier.

During the course of the story, Pablo doesn't actually change, as

Robert Jordan does. He vacillates. He is now one Pablo, now another- a

frustrating figure to Jordan, and probably to you, also.

But most of the time Pablo suffers from what we might call

burnout, exhaustion and apathy resulting usually from working too hard

at something. What's responsible for this disintegration of Pablo from

a terror-wielding firebrand to an often drunken excuse for a soldier?

Several possibilities exist. One is his dependence on wine. You

may see that as a defect of character or as a disease. Or it could

be that the responsibility of leading his band during wartime has

simply worn him down. Perhaps through lack of willpower he has allowed

fear to transform him into a spineless character. Maybe he has

simply become soft and spoiled by the relative luxuries of his

recently sheltered situation.

A particularly intriguing line of thought is that Pablo suffers from

guilt over the atrocities he engineered at the beginning of the war,

which Pilar describes in Chapter 10. Guilt can produce severe

depression leading to inactivity and even virtual paralysis. At one

point Pablo does express a sorrow for having killed and a kinship with

his victims, but it's uncertain whether this is Pablo or his red

wine speaking.



Pilar is Pablo's mistress and the real leader of the guerrilla band,

even though Pablo nominally holds the title at the beginning of the

novel. As with Pablo, there is more than one Pilar. But she is far

more predictable. In fact, you typically see only her tough side.

Whatever the situation, Pilar is always in charge.

She is duly respectful of Jordan's status with the movement and

his expertise as a demolition expert. But she is prepared to set him

straight when she feels it's needed.

She is a woman born into a male-oriented culture. Thus she is

domestic in many ways. She even trains Maria in some traditional

household and man-pleasing "duties." At the same time, she can carry

heavy equipment, fire a machine gun, and command a group of

seasoned, male guerrilla soldiers.

She is rough and hardened, capable of crude speech and outrageous

insults. She dispenses them freely, particularly to Pablo. Anyone

who strikes her as acting stupidly is a target for her acid tongue.

Though physically ugly- by her own admission- Pilar has not lacked

for lovers. She recalls her former lover Finito with a nostalgic

fondness. She is affectionate with Maria, for whom she has genuine

feelings. And her strength diminishes at times- the roar of plane

engines overhead sends her into a shudder of fear.

True to her complex character, when Pablo returns from his brief

desertion, she insults, forgives, then admires him nearly all in the

same breath.

Unlike Pablo, throughout most of the story Pilar professes to be a

fervent believer in the Republican movement as an ideal. In that

respect she is like the Robert Jordan we see at the beginning of the

story. You might question how genuine this is or at least what

motivates Pilar. You might see her as truly convinced of Republican

ideals, even though she could not articulate them in the

intellectual manner that Jordan would. Another interpretation is

that she has simply found her niche in this turbulent wartime

situation and receives sufficient psychological reward to keep her

going from her role as behind-the-scenes controller of what is

nominally Pablo's band. It might even be argued that both the above

compensate for her recent lack of romantic and sexual fulfillment with


There is also a mystical streak in Pilar. Although full of common

sense, she is attuned to mysteries of the universe. She reads Jordan's

palm and probably sees his imminent death. She also graphically

recounts the smell of death that clung to the ill-fated Kashkin,

Jordan's predecessor.



Maria is a young Spanish woman who was rescued by Pablo's band

when they hijacked a Nationalist train. She has been with them

since. Maria is important in the story as a principal cause of

character development in Robert Jordan. But many readers feel that she

herself changes little and is a superficial character. One commentator

has said that even Jordan's fantasies of love affairs with screen

goddesses are more real than the portrait of Maria.

At their first meeting, she is strongly attracted to Jordan. She

exhibits an almost desperate need for the attentions of a man who will

care for her as a woman- but with respect and tenderness.

Crucial to this need is a nightmare of Maria's past: the brutal rape

she experienced at the hands of her Nationalist captors. Pilar has

afforded some healing with her philosophy that whatever Maria didn't

actually consent to did not, in a sense, happen- or at least did not

count. But Maria needs more than this.

You might question whether Maria's willingness to give herself so

quickly and completely to Jordan is believable in light of her

previous brutal treatment at the hands of men. After all, even

though Jordan fights for the Loyalists, as a person he's an unknown

quantity to her.

Finding Jordan both masculine and gentle, Maria becomes lovingly

subservient to a degree that some women readers find somewhat silly.

She talks almost in terms of worship. As you read the novel, you'll

have to decide whether Hemingway has portrayed Maria's relationship

with Jordan in believable terms.

At the close of the story, Maria and Jordan's relationship is, in

their own words, much deeper than simple attraction and need. Has

Maria herself changed- or been changed? Or has something good (a

sincere love affair) simply happened to her while she herself

remains much the same person?





Anselmo, the oldest member of the guerrilla band, never uses his age

as an excuse for shirking work for the Republican cause. There is

nothing half-hearted about his service. Above all, he exhibits

simplicity and integrity. Many readers feel that when Anselmo

speaks, it's worth listening to.

Anselmo is also a gentle, sensitive man who is able to see enemy

soldiers as men very much like himself. The killing involved in the

guerrilla band's operations causes him much pain. At heart he is a

deeply religious man.

Thus, even in a situation he did not devise or wish for, Anselmo

seems to be an example of an honest gentleman. His integrity

combined with the nominal atheism he must subscribe to on behalf of

the Republicans have gained him the epithet "secular saint" in some


Yet it's possible to see him in another light. Given the depth of

his religious and ethical convictions, which become particularly

evident at the end of the novel, why hasn't he simply stood up and

said "I will not serve" a cause which exercises the killing and

brutality which he hates?



Golz is a Soviet military strategist who is in Spain to help the

Republican forces. But it's difficult to determine his personal

involvement in the cause. He devotes himself to his job, and he's

upset (as Jordan will be) at the incompetent manner in which the

Loyalists wage the war. He is resentful that amateurish bumbling and

pettiness prevent his strategic plans from being carried out as he has


This could be explained by a sincere belief in his communist

ideology and a desire to see justice and self-determination granted to

the common people of Spain. It could also stem from a love of

playing professional war games and a desire for a sparkling military

record. Golz, after all, will not answer to the people of Spain. He

answers to superiors who will determine his career as a Soviet




El Sordo ("The Deaf One") is the leader of a neighboring guerrilla

band. He's an aggressive leader such as Pablo once was, although

perhaps without the cruelty. He's courageous, resourceful, and

dedicated to the Republic.

But he's also a realist: he has no illusions about the possibility

of Republican success in the civil war. In this respect, he can be

seen as the purest example of devotion to an ideal. He knows that

the cause for which he will die will fail. Yet he does more than he

has to on its behalf. He even gives Jordan (who is expected to

return to the luxury of the United States) a rare bottle of whiskey in

hospitable thanks for Jordan's aid toward the cause.

He can also be seen as a contradictory character. Although he does

not accept the collectivist slogans that promise victory or at least

glory through sustained effort, he fights with all his effort on

behalf of the force which generates them.



Karkov is a Soviet journalist covering the Spanish Civil War from

his headquarters in Madrid. He seems to give allegiance to the

ideology of the Republic. Consequently, the bumbling and

indifference that he observes in many of its higher echelons disgust

and infuriate him.

He's similar to Golz in that it's difficult to determine how

personally he's involved in the cause. While on the surface he seems

genuine, he doesn't hesitate to avail himself of the relatively

extravagant luxuries at Gaylord's Hotel, the Soviet headquarters in

Madrid. In this manner, he could easily symbolize many who have thrown

themselves into the cause of the common, impoverished people- but

without truly wanting to share their general lot in life.



Joaquin is a young, idealistic member of El Sordo's band. At the

time of the air attack on the guerrillas, Joaquin at first is a

vocal partisan of the communist cause. But as the attack begins and

the possibility of death looms, Joaquin returns to his Roman

Catholic roots and begins to pray fervently.



Andres is a member of Pablo's band. He is sent by Jordan to

deliver the message to General Golz that the planned Republican

offensive has been anticipated by the enemy.






Because For Whom the Bell Tolls is set during the Spanish Civil War,

it is important to know some of the elements of Spanish geography

incorporated in the book. If you look at the series of maps entitled

"The Course of the Spanish Civil War," (see illustration)


notice the increase of Nationalist-held territory from July 1936 to

October 1937. (The novel takes place in May 1937.) By 1937 the

Republicans were steadily losing ground, and Robert Jordan's

mission- to blow up a bridge crucial to enemy Nationalist interests-

takes on added importance.

Almost in the center of Spain is Madrid, the capital, once a

Republican stronghold, but in May 1937 close to falling to the

enemy. To the north of Madrid (see map) is the Guadarrama

Range, where

Pablo's band is hiding and where the bridge is to be demolished. The

town of La Granja is where members of the band go for supplies and

news of the war. To the southwest of the Guadarrama mountains is the

Gredos Range, where Pablo intends to retreat after the bridge is blown

up. To the west of the Guadarrama Range is the city of Segovia, a

Nationalist stronghold the Republicans hope to capture in their


Farther northwest of Segovia is Valladolid, where Maria was taken

prisoner. It was there she was transported by the train that Pablo's

band seized and blew up.

Notice, too, the region of Estremadura in the western part of Spain,

where Jordan was working before his current assignment.

Many readers have pointed out that one of Ernest Hemingway's major

goals in writing For Whom the Bell Tolls was to demonstrate that the

real victims of the Spanish Civil War were the Spanish people

themselves, torn by the savage self-interest of the competing

political ideologues. The tragic effects of a brutal war on the

peasants for whom it had become a daily reality are revealed in the

rebel camp where Jordan and the others are hiding. These simple,

earthy people have been transformed permanently by the war, and its

toll is immeasurable. Hemingway shows us the cost of war in a

variety of ways: Pilar's lengthy and vivid description of the

atrocities inflicted upon Nationalist enemies in her village;

Maria's suffering at the hands of the enemy; Pablo's erratic behavior;

Anselmo's pathetic conflict between loyalty to the cause and his

dislike of killing, to name the most obvious examples. Because the

fate of the Spanish people (mostly farmers) is so directly tied to the

land the war has ravaged, they act as an indivisible part of the

novel's setting.

By placing most of the action in the mountain retreat of the

guerrilla band, Hemingway has created a setting that is symbolic in

contrasting ways. On the one hand, the camp hidden in the Guadarrama

Range is a refuge that offers safety for many of the characters.

Here Pablo, Pilar, and the other guerrillas have come to find

temporary safety; here, too, Maria has come to heal physical and

psychic wounds after her imprisonment by the Nationalists. It is in

the mountains that Robert Jordan begins to question his motives as a

participant in this war: through his love for Maria and his

association with the peasants, Jordan is humanized and slowly comes to

realize the truth of the quotation from John Donne at the opening of

the novel: "No man is an Iland."

On the other hand, the mountain hideout also represents the plight

of the Republicans- there they are trapped, blocked by fascist

troops below them and enemy aircraft whizzing over their heads. The

snow of the mountains offers a similar two-sided symbol: beautiful

to look at, it suggests nature at its most peaceful, but the snow is

also deadly, since it reveals the whereabouts of the rebels once

they have walked in it.




Until the 1930s Spain had been a monarchy for centuries, except

for a brief experiment as a republic in 1873-74. We can begin the

background to the Spanish Civil War with Alfonso XIII, who came to the

Spanish throne in 1902. The general verdict of historians is that he

was incompetent. In 1921, for example, 20,000 Spanish troops died in

an ill-conceived, unsuccessful offensive that he ordered against

Moroccan tribes. He subsequently disbanded Parliament and selected

Miguel Primo de Rivera as a military dictator.

Rivera established a dictatorship with Alfonso as figurehead.

Although Rivera's government, which held power from 1923 to 1930,

initially proved efficient and was widely favored, its popularity

later declined and finally even the army withdrew its support.

Rivera fled in January 1930, leaving Alfonso with the huge problem

of trying to run Spain with little popular support.

In the hope of avoiding civil war, Alfonso went into exile,

attempting to do so with a touch of grace by not officially

abdicating. In 1931 the Second Republic, led by a coalition of

Socialists and middle-class liberals, was formed amid enthusiasm.

But the new government tried to do too much too quickly- and often

acted unwisely. This was especially the case in matters of educational

reform and in trying to reduce the immense power of both the church

and the army.

Consequently, opposition mounted. Monarchist plots arose on behalf

of Alfonso and even on behalf of the line of Don Carlos, the

19th-century claimant to the throne. By the end of 1935,

twenty-eight governments had been formed and had fallen. The country

was close to chaos, with frequent strikes and uprisings by

self-declared autonomous governments.

The election of February 1936 gave power to the Popular Front, a

shaky mixture of Republicans, Socialists, Communists, and

Anarchists. But widescale disorder and violence continued to rack

the country. Spain had finally gained a government "of the people,"

but the Republic was weak and inefficient- and thus its own worst


The situation begged for a force to bring order out of chaos and

hence was ripe for the formation and growth of fascist organizations

based on the premise of a strong central government. Principal among

the fascist groups was the Falange, begun by Jose Antonio Primo de

Rivera, the son of the previous dictator, Miguel Primo de Rivera.

Many tradition-minded Spanish people, particularly the landowners

and conservative army officers, began to feel that their way of life

would be destroyed either by official government reforms or by the

general chaos of the country. They started planning to overthrow the


The army made its move on July 17, 1936, charging that the

government could not keep order. It was certainly not the first

fighting in Spain. But it was the beginning of large-scale civil

war, with the lines clearly drawn.

The forces led by the army (with General Francisco Franco in charge)

were called the Nationalists or Rebels. Supporting the Nationalists

were monarchists, Carlists (monarchists who supported the claim of

descendants of Don Carlos, rather than the Bourbon line), the

wealthy upper classes, the Falange fascists, and elements of the Roman

Catholic Church.

The forces defending the Republican government were called Loyalists

or Republicans. This group included much of the working class and most

liberals, socialists, and communists.

The Spanish Civil War was a brutal conflict that included many

appalling acts of cruelty and terrorism. The Nationalist forces

often found themselves in the position of an alien invading army.

Popular sympathy was usually with the Republicans, but the support was

largely passive. One way the Nationalists tried to gain control of

people was through terror: torture, executions, and bloodletting of

all kinds. Loyalists responded with equally reprehensible

atrocities, like those described in Chapter 10 of For Whom the Bell


The Spanish Civil War was, in part, an international affair.

Historians have often commented that the war served as a training

ground, almost a dress rehearsal, for World War II.

Aiding the Nationalists were approximately 50,000 soldiers from

Fascist Italy, 20,000 from Portugal, and 10,000 from Nazi Germany.

These countries also provided modern war materials.

On the Republican side were Soviet soldiers, well trained and able

to assume positions of leadership, and an estimated 40,000

additional volunteers from around the globe, including the United

States. The volunteers were mostly professional soldiers for hire,

international adventurers, or persons who sympathized ideologically

with the Republicans. This last group included people like Robert

Jordan, the main character in For Whom the Bell Tolls.

Some arms and equipment were sent to the Loyalists from such

countries as the Soviet Union, Mexico, and France, but this aid didn't

equal that provided to the Nationalists. Consequently, Nationalist

forces were nearly always better equipped.

The Nationalist rebels began by occupying the northwest and the

southern tip of Spain and gradually linked these two areas. From there

they executed a pincer movement: down from the north, up from the

south, and toward the Mediterranean coast in the east.

By the spring of 1937, when For Whom the Bell Tolls takes place, the

Nationalists were making serious inroads in Republican-controlled

territory. Madrid, the Spanish capital, was held by the Republicans

but was constantly under siege. The guerrilla camp depicted by

Hemingway in the novel was behind Nationalist lines, about sixty miles

from Madrid. It was also during this time, on April 26, that Nazi

German airplanes bombed the Basque town of Guernica, killing more than

1600 civilians. Guernica was without military importance, and the

bombing brought an international outcry of protest. The incident

also inspired one of Spanish painter Pablo Picasso's most vivid and

moving paintings, called Guernica, created out of his heartbreak and


Yet for all the Nationalist gains in 1937, the Republicans

remained hopeful they could win the war. Hemingway has called this

period of brave optimism "the happiest period of our lives," referring

to those sympathizers and journalists who were in Spain. But less than

two years later, in March 1939, Madrid was captured by the

Nationalists, and the war was over.

The toll in human lives was immense. Nearly 110,000 people died in

battles and air raids. Some 220,000 persons were murdered or executed.

About 200,000 Loyalist prisoners were shot or died of ill-treatment in

prison cells even after the Nationalist triumph. And more than 300,000

people sought exile abroad.




The following are themes of For Whom the Bell Tolls.





Hemingway's choice of a John Donne poem as the source of the novel's

title and epigraph emphasizes a major theme of For Whom the Bell

Tolls: "No man is an iland," that is, no person can exist separate

from the lives of others, even others living in far-away countries.

The theme is demonstrated most clearly by the actions of Robert

Jordan. Throughout his participation in the Spanish Civil War, he

has fought actively for a cause- not the cause of communism, as he

says, but the cause of antifascism. As the novel progresses, his

involvement with the guerrilla band, and particularly his love for

Maria, teach him the value of the individual as he or she affects a

larger society. The abstractions of an ideology are lifeless without

the people they represent; concepts have no meaning except for the

ways in which they affect human beings.

For Jordan, Maria represents human love, the first he has ever

known. It is for her that he stays behind to allow the rest of the

band to escape, demonstrating his realization that others depend on

him as he has depended on them. His decision not to commit suicide

at the end of the novel represents his ultimate understanding that

he must fight for the people whose lives are affected by the cause,

not purely for the cause as a generalized ideology.

Both Pablo and Pilar represent minor variations of the theme of

interdependency. Pablo is full of greedy self-interest now that he

owns horses. His decision to betray the guerrilla band is due to his

need to survive and thrive. At the last minute, however, he seems to

understand how his actions will affect those whom he once led, and

he returns to help them. Pilar, on the other hand, is almost blindly

devoted to the cause. She will do whatever it takes to win for the

Republic. Yet she, too, comes to understand the severe toll the

guerrillas' mission is likely to take, and for the first time she

expresses doubt about the cause that prompted the demolition.



Who wants the Spanish Civil War? Is anyone likely to benefit from

it? Look for answers to these questions as you read For Whom the

Bell Tolls. There is much to suggest that the common people, on

whose behalf the war is supposedly being waged, are tired of the

war, uninterested in it, and unlikely to benefit from it. Readers have

pointed out that Hemingway was prompted in part to write For Whom

the Bell Tolls to show his disgust at the way in which the civil war

had betrayed the Spanish people, both through internal disputes

between the warring factions and through foreign intervention eager

for a testing ground for an upcoming war.

The war's effect on the Spanish is demonstrated in acts of great

courage and great cruelty. The challenges of the struggle created both

the bloodthirstiness and greed of Pablo, as well as the steadfast

courage of Pilar and Anselmo. The war may have exacted a terrible

price from its people, Hemingway seems to be saying, but it often

revealed them at their best.

Despite his pro-Republican leanings, Hemingway is careful to point

out that both sides are capable of savage behavior and that each

side is peopled with human beings with similar human needs. Through

Robert Jordan, Hemingway describes how a foreigner comes to view the


ähnliche Referate John F. Kennedy
Literarische Entwicklung ab 1945
Alfred Andersch
Alfred Andersch Literaturbesprechung

Hier könnt Ihr die DRUCKANSICHT für das Referat öffnen


(c) 2004-2018

MEDIADATEN --- Besucher seit dem 01.09.2006
gesamt: 6671791 - heute: 111 - gestern: 959 - online: 8 - Rekord online: 340 - Rekord Tag: 2801

ID: 5322      Aufrufe seit dem 02.08.2011: 1471